Monday, December 7, 2009

Rachel: Children Deserve Great Art

First off, let me just say that I'm thrilled to be a new nester and honored to be among the company of so many illustrious writers! On to my post...

I saw Fantastic Mr. Fox a few weekends ago, and I absolutely loved it. I am a big fan of both Wes Anderson and analog animation, and it was hilarious and touching and visually fascinating. I keep hearing debate about whether or not this movie is for kids. A.O. Scott in his New York Times review asks, “Is it is a movie for children? This inevitable question depends on the assumption that children have uniform tastes and expectations. How can that be?” I think his point is that children are people. They have preferences.
Whenever I hear someone say, “I don’t like kids,” I am reminded that folks get it in their heads that the very young and the very old are somehow "not people" and that the ways they are and the things they want must be very different from the things that "adults" want. I just can't get behind that. I really believe that children can have good taste, that they can understand complex emotions and that they can appreciate films and books that are beautiful and ambiguous.
Recent waves of criticism of high-quality children’s programming strike me as odd. Fantastic Mr. Fox is too complicated, Cookie Monster is a bad influence on fat kids, and, reaching back a few years, Harry Potter is against God. Yet, I don’t hear too much criticism of the ultra-violent, ultra-simplistic stuff that counts as family fun these days: The Dark Knight, Transformers, or any of the myriad violent video games (take your pick). When I look at what gets critiqued, I get the feeling that the point is not to protect children from something, but rather make ourselves feel better about the world we inhabit without attempting to change it too much.
There are so many things that aren't appropriate for children around the world: racism, poverty, substance abuse, bad health, negative role models, bad parenting, political or tribal violence, insidious advertising, unhealthy food, bad drivers, precocious sexuality. Unfortunately, many children are right in the thick of it. Hell, they live in the same beautiful, terrible, inappropriate, ultimately ambiguous world we live in, too, don't they?
Instead of erasing or evading difficult subjects, or reducing hard topics to the easy good-versus-evil killing sprees that you can see in a kids movie such as Transformers, can’t there be a way to reflect these difficult subjects in a satisfying way back to children? Isn’t this one of the functions of art? I paraphrase Lynda Barry when I say, “We don’t make art to leave the world, we make art so that we can stay.”
I’ve been thinking about Cookie Monster and his recent health-conscious choices. While it was just a rumor that he’s now “Veggie Monster,” he still says that cookies are a “sometimes food,” and talks about his love for healthy food, too. There’s nothing wrong with that, I guess, but I don’t get what demon they’re trying to exorcise. I don’t think anyone who saw Cookie Monster as a child thought that he was a role model to emulate. I think instead Cookie Monster functioned as a cultural hero precisely because he was a manifestation of an unconscious childhood desire, the very real desire to pig out on cookies! We all knew that we weren’t supposed to do it, but we got great joy out of seeing him do it. We saw ourselves reflected in him, that was what made him so magnetic.
Another great example is the Harry Potter series. Harry Potter appeals to children, I think we can safely say that. There are many levels on which to appreciate the Harry Potter books, but I think one of the most interesting is all the tragedy that he lives through. He’s pulled out of an abusive situation (living with the Dursleys) to go to Hogwarts, but tragedy strikes him again and again. By the time he’s ostensibly a senior in high school many of the people closest to him have died due to political violence. I think that children who live tragic lives can see themselves reflected in Harry’s pain.
There are many other books, films, and TV shows that are full of ambiguity, tragedy, and joy that spoke to me as a child. Another striking factor about quality culture for children is that it can be appreciated on more than one level. There’s enough slapstick and cute animation in Mr. Fox to keep anyone entertained, just as there’s enough adventure and characterization in Narnia to allow the allegories to slip under the radar until you’re old enough to understand them. I can now appreciate the language in a Jacqueline Woodson or S.E. Hinton novel while I probably more appreciated having characters with which to identify when I read them as a kid.
Like A.O. Scott says in his review of Fantastic Mr. Fox, “There are some children — some people — who will embrace it with a special, strange intensity, as if it had been made for them alone.” That’s a great description, and pretty much sums up how I felt about all my favorite books and films as a kid. Actually, I feel the same way now when I encounter the uncanny in art (animation is especially good at this); when literature or art represents something that is so pitch-perfectly familiar that you stop and give that "hey!" of recognition over and over as you read/view. It is this recognition, this feeling of having something in your culture reflect you, or say something that you can't say, or that you want to hear someone else say finally for the love of pete! that makes art (literature/film) so emotionally powerful. It’s what makes you laugh out loud at something tragic represented on the page, simply because you couldn’t have said it better yourself.
Literature/art/film has the power to reaffirm and make sense of life, simply by telling it like it is instead of avoiding unpleasantness. I think children deserve that high quality in cultural forms directed at them as well. If anyone does, children do, precisely because it is even more urgent that they make sense of the world they’ve just arrived in.


  1. sharp and true! thank you for saying it.

  2. I just had a baby (one year ago). This post brought up some murky "stuff."
    Like - why don't I make art anymore? What was the last art I had "time" for? Is Felix (baby) exposed to enough??
    Very angry with a book I was reading to Felix the other day. It had computer generated illustrations and really dull text. I wanted to throw it out the window! I understand simplicity, but what about using beautiful lines and colors to achieve it?
    To me, one must be VERY artful to achieve simplicity.
    Just because Felix is one does NOT mean he will be interested in drawings made on a computer by some fool's imitation of a smiling lion. To boot - why should I have to suffer through a children's book when in general they bring me joy?
    Yes! Give us babies AND mamas ART!!!! We are not as simple as we look.

  3. Happy Agent Day, Sara!
    Thanks for all you do. :)

  4. Now you can hire call girls in Jaipur or escorts in Jaipur for escort services in Jaipur. To hire Jaipur call girls or Jaipur escorts all you need is to visit our official website from the link given bellow

    Hire seductive escorts in Jaipur or call girls in Jaipur for incall or outcall hotel escort services. We provide hot Jaipur escorts or Jaipur call girls to clients for escort service in Jaipur top class hotels. Visit our website from the link given bellow:-

    Check out our official website of Sehzadi escorts for escort services in Jaipur. We are top class female escort provider in Jaipur and cater genuine escort service in Jaipur 2/3/4/5 stars hotels. Our call girls in Jaipur or escorts in Jaipur are educated and well mannered. You can easily book Jaipur escorts or Jaipur call girls from the link given bellow:-

    Visit our official website of Sweeti-sinha if you want escort service in Jaipur. Sweeti-sinha is one of the best escort agency to cater escort services in jaipur. We provide hot call girls in Jaipur or escorts in jaipur for incall or outcall facility to clients. To hire Jaipur call girls or Jaipur escorts simply click on the link:-

  5. Priyanka ji is Gurgaon based number one escort agency. They offer unlimited adult services and able to full fill all your hidden fantasies. If you are looking for the call girls in gurgaon, search the net now! We offer the best gurgaon escorts and luxury service as well. Presently, most of the business owners, politicians, and rich people prefer escort service because it makes them secure. Sometimes, people are frustrated, tired or want to make some fun in their personal life, for them escort service is one of the best.

    |Escorts In Gurgaon |
    |Escorts In Mumbai |
    |Call Girls In Gurgaon|

    |Call Girl In Mumbai |
    |Call Girl In Gurgaon |
    |Gurgaon Escorts |

    |Gurgaon Escorts |
    |Gurgaon Call Girl |
    |Call Girl In Andheri |


    |Gurgaon Call Girls |
    |Escorts In Gurgaon |
    |Escorts In Bangalore |
    |Call girls In Bangalore |

  6. I Saw Your Website Carefully. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. Your All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. I Say Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also. I Am Ritu Sharma. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Deal In Mumbai Escorts service. I Am Very Hot And Sexy. Being A Mumbai Escort Girl I Have Five Years’ Experience. That’s Why I Understand The Each Personal Needs Of My Every Client. My Service Charge Is Low And Service Is Super. You Can Avail My VIP Mumbai Escorts Service At Your Home Or In Hotel. I Am Comfortable To Provide Mumbai Escorts Service In Local And Outside Also. Visit Call +91- 9OO4OO9481
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
    Mumbai Escorts
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mumbai Escorts In Vile

    Bandra Escorts
    Juhu Escorts
    Andheri Escorts
    Mumbai Escorts In Colaba

  7. Thanks For Create Such Kind Of Informative Website. All Content Is Relevant To Your Subject. Keep It Continue, Because Your Website And Subject Is Meaningful For The Users. After See Your Niche I Have Recommended Your Website With My Friends Also.
    My Name Is Priya Singh. I Run My Own Mumbai Escorts Service. I Am An Independent Mumbai Escort Girl. I Am Beautiful And Hot. My Service Charge Is Low And Service Is Super. Being Professional I Have Seven Years’ Experience As An Escort Girl. So I Understand And Feel The Real Needs And Requirement Of My Each Client. You Can Taste Me Any Time. According The Convenience You Can Avail My VIP Escort Service At Your Home Or In Hotel Also. To Book My VIP Mumbai Escort Service Call +91 9987215552. Visit
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-
    Mumbai Call Girls
    Mumbai Escorts In Vile Parle

  8. My name is Arpita Jain. I run my independent Mumbai Escorts Service. I am an independent Mumbai escort girl. My service charge is low according the current market price. My service is super, because I know very well the personal requirement of my each customer. I am comfortable to provide my Mumbai Escorts Service at your home or in Hotel. Visit- Call- +91 9OO4458359
    Visit The Links Below And Have A Look At My Various Mumbai Escort Services-

    Mumbai Escorts Service
    Mumbai Escort Girls
    Juhu Escorts

    Escort Service In Mumbai

  9. Hello dude,
    Thanks For Create Such a very Informative blog. All Content Is Relevant To about your Subject. Keep It Continue, Because It's gives some things about crowe's nest, By the way, If anyone searching for Best Payment Gateway UAE. Visit my profile

  10. Glad to go to your post, i'm apparently forward to an ever increasing number of trustworthy Mumbai Escorts articles and that I figure we tend to as a full might want to pass on such Brobdingnagian quantities of amazing articles, present like on essential to us.

  11. It provides an opportunity to acquire a better experience. With us you may surely likely to have a really memorable experience. Independent escorts Jodhpur provides you an offer of online booking from which you are able to readily communicate with our escorts to discuss your curiosity with her prior to availing the ceremony.
    Jodhpur call girls
    Udaipur escorts
    Jaipur Call Girls

  12. Each of the call girl in Goa is character friendly all call girls are well high tech and higher standing history. Each of the men come there Goa escorts provides his client of privacy and safety. The entire individual visit marina beach escorts this service isn't sent message or do not call his clientele and his title and phone number is quite solitude.
    Goa Call Girls
    Udaipur call girls
    Ahmadabad Call Girls.
    Hyderbad Call Girls

  13. Walk the roads of Nainital with natural allure of Nainital. Nainital escorts have appealing attributes, classy design and silky-smooth hair which make them ideal for the day. The stunning women align themselves perfectly. The allure of the outcall Nainital escorts can cause you to enthusiast of these and encourage you to invest some time together daily.
    Nainital Call Girls
    Haldwani Call Girls
    Ramnagar Call Girls
    Nainital Call Girls
    Rudrapur Call Girls
    Dehradun Call Girls
    Haridwar Call Girls
    Rishikesh Call Girls
    Mussoorie Call girls

  14. Our Dehradun escorts service never experienced in this industry but the grade of support people provides the grade of expertise, imply that our service is extremely professional and supply superlative scale of gratification.
    Dehradun Escorts
    Dehradun Call Girls
    Haridwar Escorts
    Rishikesh Escorts
    Mussoorie Escorts
    Ramnagar Escorts
    Haldwani Escorts
    Nainital Escorts

  15. Our dedication will be to have all the required licenses and licenses to lawfully function as an escort service in Patna, and it is possible to be very sure everything is legal and you won't have any issues if you've got among our escort in Agra right on your hotel room. We're known for our escort service and also, we can supply you with a gorgeous escort within half an hour.
    Patna Call Girls
    Jaipur Call Girls
    Agra Call Girls
    Surat Call Girls
    Faridabad Call Girls

  16. Escorts service spend your quality time with hot and super model in India I am 100% sure use of our escort girl one time you will again want to meet her full girlfriend feeling
    Mumbai Independent escorts

    Hyderabad Independent escorts

    Hyderabad Independent escorts

    Jalandhar Independent escorts

    Chandigarh Independent escorts

  17. This is a very good post you made. You have explained things very well in this post. And the knowledge that you have is very good on this topic, which we have liked very much. You continued to work like this and kept telling us such good things.
    Our Services:
    Digital marketing Company
    SMM Services
    PPC Ads Services
    PPC Services in Delhi
    Website Design & Development Packages
    Our Service Partners
    Refrigerator Repair Service
    Satta King
    B2B Marketplace

  18. Gurgaon is a famous place for receiving gurgaon call girls. Here call girls are categorized as many categories, you can contact us on our website to get them.Cheap Call Girls In Gurgaon